Reviews

I tend to go later, so it has never been busy for me. Each time I've gotten a seat right away and have had more then satisfactory service. A small complaint would be that it has seemed to take a long time to get the food and/or refills which could just be a run of bad luck. The calzones are very good and I tend to make my own which a ... read more
Shade Lion via google.com - May 22, 2018
Outstanding food and service! We ...
Outstanding food and service! We had the breadsticks to start, a generous order with loads of cheese and flavor. My husband had the lasagna and I had the antipasto salad, both orders were outstanding. If I lived on Montrose, this would be my favorite restaurant. Our server, Katie was attentive and courteous.
Didi D. via yelp.com - May 20, 2018
My wife and I really enjoy this restaurant. Great food, great service every time we have been here!
Ken Cordonnier via google.com - May 17, 2018
Great experience ... read more
Charlie D via google.com - May 15, 2018
Good pizza ... read more
Mary Decker via google.com - May 13, 2018
Not a fan of the marinara here, but the food is decent.
J Phil via google.com - May 5, 2018
I think the reason for so many ...
I think the reason for so many good reviews is that there just aren't any good Italian restaurants in this part of Colorado so the pickins are slim.I'm not saying this place is really bad but it's just not all that great either.Pizza is generic as though all the ingredients came from the National Pizza Convention vendors show. Nothin ... read more
Torque T. via yelp.com - May 4, 2018
Outstanding Food and Service!
Pahgre’s came highly recommend and didn’t disappoint. I had the special, it was a homemade butternut squash ravioli with a creamy red pepper sauce with a homemade meatball on top. The flavor combination was out of this world! The whole menu looked delicious and I...More ... read more
IdahoGal801 via tripadvisor.com - May 3, 2018
Love this place, don't mind driving a hour to get here ... read more
Joshua Bruno via google.com - May 2, 2018
Awesome pizza and good service!
Hannah Jones via google.com - Apr 26, 2018
Great food and service ... read more
Chris Warren via google.com - Apr 22, 2018
We got takeout here at least 3 times. Food is very good. Servers and staff we friendly. The food was on time and they provided extra stuff. They have a good size menu. Clean place.
Stephen Castrogiovanni via google.com - Apr 20, 2018
Meals and service are outstanding!!! I never have a bad experience when my family and i go there. Amazing beers and never see an employee without a smile. Recommend HIGHLY ... read more
Ashalee Canavan via google.com - Apr 12, 2018
Love, Love, Love this place. This ...
Love, Love, Love this place. This is my most favorite restaurant in Montrose and eat there at least once a week. Their pizza is unique and the flavor combinations are balanced and delicious. The garita and bleu mesa are my favorite. I also fell in love with their pasta, especially the ravioli with spicy sausage. Say hi to Ashley! She ... read more
Maren S. via yelp.com - Apr 7, 2018
I remember "food allergies beware". I was there and it was not the staff or owner who were obnoxious. The food is great and I visit every time I'm in town. The Mesa Verde salad in superb!
Averil Loague via google.com - Mar 31, 2018
I was in Pahgre's when "food allergies ...
I was in Pahgre's when "food allergies beware" was there. The staff and owner were not the obnoxious ones.
Averil L. via yelp.com - Mar 31, 2018
Great Food and Great People. Highly Recommend!!!!
Terry Miller via google.com - Mar 25, 2018
Great service, food was good, location was very clean if not spotless. Decent selection of food. 4/5 due to prices that seemed to be on the higher side.
Derek Peck via google.com - Mar 23, 2018
Go to Pizza
Pahgre's is always fresh and quality food. Pizza is best in town. Atmosphere for the dine in crown is laid back and service is great.
Sandy T via tripadvisor.com - Mar 3, 2018
One of the best in Montrose
Okay, so we're picky. However, we keep going back to Pagre's, so that says a lot. Montrose has several mediocre restaurants, but this is not one of them. The Pizza and pasta selections are quite enjoyable, and their salads do the trick. This is a...More ... read more
JoJoBoHo5656 via tripadvisor.com - Feb 12, 2018
Three stars, but only because the ...
Three stars, but only because the front of house staff was great.  The food... gross.  Gluten free pizzas were undercooked and everything was super bland.  No interesting menu items, we felt like we were at pizza hut.  We had the "Lizard Head Luau" and "Precipice Peak Pesto" but left with almost two full pizzas.  The only thing more ... read more
Sumira P. via yelp.com - Jan 26, 2018
Took an ungodly ammount of time for the food to come, but its worth it!
his name is monique via google.com - Jan 19, 2018
I absolutely loved my food and the atmosphere and I had an incredible waitress that was awesome ... read more
Jenna Rovelstad via google.com - Jan 14, 2018
Awesome food - the staff is very friendly and the pizza rocks!
Awesome food - the staff is very friendly and the pizza rocks!
Roger Fisher via facebook.com - Dec 24, 2017
Great food and great service ... read more
Bobbygrim via google.com - Dec 21, 2017
Great food!!! Great prices!!! And great customer service!!! I recommend this every time someone is wanting a family friendly pizzaria!!!
Luke JOhnson via google.com - Dec 13, 2017
We love Pahgre's. The staff is ...
We love Pahgre's. The staff is excellent. Often we go on "Date Night" and we are always greeted with welcoming staff. The food is great. We love to share a fresh pizza and salad!  I would highly recommend.
Michelle K. via yelp.com - Dec 12, 2017
Fantastic on all counts
Stopped into this restaurant for the first time on a recommendation from a colleague who lives in town. Was so pleased with the friendly service and the wonderful food. Ordered a salad and a calzone and wasn't disappointed. Will definitely return to this restaurant next...More ... read more
Allison R via tripadvisor.com - Dec 6, 2017
I think this is a good restaurant. It's ...
I think this is a good restaurant. It's convenient as it's right by Wal-Mart. I took my wife on our first date there because they have gluten free options. They went through an ownership change but the menu is largely intact.
Tanner Carson via zomato.com - Nov 23, 2017
I've never had anything better! I ordered 2 plates... THE Mushroom Ravioli is so far beyond awesom
I've never had anything better! I ordered 2 plates... THE Mushroom Ravioli is so far beyond awesome I can't explain!
David Fradkin via facebook.com - Nov 17, 2017
Just passing by for a take out ...
Just passing by for a take out and we were not disappointed. Attended fast, order was taken right away, took just about right for a fresh pizza to come out. And of course food is great.
PJ T. via yelp.com - Nov 9, 2017
This place is the BEST! If you're ...
This place is the BEST! If you're looking for an engaging experience, then this is the place. Great food, knowledgeable staff who actually know what is on the menu. Local wines, family friendly.
Sjerry K. via yelp.com - Oct 27, 2017
Love , Pahgre's, I usually have ...
Love , Pahgre's, I usually have the purgatory pesto, I just can't get enough of it. My second favorite is shrimp pizza with white is to die for. Love the atmosphere it's rustic cool. Stephanie was my waitress today and she was a smiling breath of fresh air.I would highly recommend .
Bernadette W. via yelp.com - Oct 27, 2017
Amazing food, service and atmosphere. Loved it and will be back for sure!
Amazing food, service and atmosphere. Loved it and will be back for sure!
Colleen Harner via facebook.com - Oct 19, 2017
Delicious! Very good ! Very sweet waitress! Good local wine!
Debbie Ritchie via google.com - Oct 14, 2017
Friendly staff that did a good job. The group enjoyed dinner of which many had either pizza or salad. I choose the spaghetti with meat sauce which was pretty bland but not bad just flavorless. I also had the house Chianti which was decent but also served in a proper red wine glass (cudos).
John Lorimer via google.com - Oct 11, 2017
Pahgre's is not the same since DaVito's took over the operation
Pahgre's used to be the best pizza place on Montrose and their salads were amazing too. As is often the case when a new operator takes over, the restaurant has declined since it was reopened a few years ago. The pizza was average the salad...More ... read more
673jaya via tripadvisor.com - Oct 3, 2017
Pizza and more
Nice atmosphere, reasonably priced with great selection for pizza, calzones, paninis, and salads. Fast and friendly service. Our GPS took us to the drive into the shopping district, but until you know where it is, signage is not obvious. From Hwy 550 turn East on...More ... read more
Robert P via tripadvisor.com - Sep 19, 2017
What an outstanding place! Friendly ...
What an outstanding place! Friendly service outstanding food with flavor and the best part of all. For the amount of food you get for the prices you pay. Wow! Loved it. Will be back again!
Michael C. via yelp.com - Sep 16, 2017
The best pizza in the area.
Eric Davis via google.com - Aug 28, 2017
Love the Pesto Brusheta!!!!
Jessica Kipp via google.com - Aug 12, 2017
Delicious artisan pizza, calzones & pasta dishes. Unique flavorful salads. Good selection of local beers. Friendly, professional staff provides excellent thorough and prompt service.
Chuck Vanderwist via google.com - Aug 8, 2017
GREAT food, good service, bad access
Stopped by for dinner - had a pizza, calzone and salad. Everything was AWESOME with the highlight being the dough on the calzone ask for honey on the side for dipping! This place is easy to see but hard to get to - use Walmart...More ... read more
Groovydky via tripadvisor.com - Jul 28, 2017
Great food
This is one of our favorite restaurants in town. The branches (breadsticks) are a nice way to start off dinner. My Husband loves the pizza, which they have a great selection. I love the cowboy calzone. It's enough for dinner and lunch the next day....More ... read more
shquilt9 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 19, 2017
Food is good. Service was friendly and efficient, even while being slammed by a few local swim teams. They could use more beers on tap. ... read more
James Speed via google.com - Jul 9, 2017
Service was excellent. Wish I'd ...
Service was excellent. Wish I'd gotten her name but she was funny and attentive. Food was better that average. We had the mud pie for dessert and it was phenomenal.
Lola S. via yelp.com - Jul 8, 2017
We had a great pizza here. Pepperoni, mushroom and green pepper. Almost more than two of us could e
We had a great pizza here. Pepperoni, mushroom and green pepper. Almost more than two of us could eat. I wish I would have had room to try their pizza cookie. It looked good. Very friendly service. If you are in Montrose and feeling like a pizza, this is the place for you.
Richard Harris via facebook.com - Jun 22, 2017
Very friendly waitstaff and hostess ...
Very friendly waitstaff and hostess, as well as delicious salad and pizza. Clean, open space, not stuffy and over-garlic-smelling like many Italian places.
Ali R. via yelp.com - Jun 21, 2017
Delicious food, great people, awesome ...
Delicious food, great people, awesome catering! We have dined in many times and each time leave full and satisfied. Their calzones are amazing! They also catered my wedding, and we were so happy with their service and pasta. So delicious!
Callie D. via yelp.com - Jun 20, 2017
Wonderful to work with when they catered our daughter's wedding. Kind, professional, on time and ju
Wonderful to work with when they catered our daughter's wedding. Kind, professional, on time and just exceptional service. Oh- and the food was delicious!
Ivy Holgate Fife via facebook.com - Jun 18, 2017
Pahgre's is delicious every time we dine in, but the real reason I am giving them five stars is for
Pahgre's is delicious every time we dine in, but the real reason I am giving them five stars is for the awesome job they did catering my small wedding. Teri was very responsive to all of our requests and willing to make changes for us. We had the food delivered with a smile and it was warm and delicious! Everyone at the wedding loved ... read more
Callie Mae DeRosia via facebook.com - Jun 18, 2017
Wonderful service and food.  I ...
Wonderful service and food.  I love the tossed salad with the fruit and the dressing that comes with it.  The calzones are a little heavy for me but the paninis are terrific as are the pizzas.  I have been there several times and each time the service and food is excellent.
Carole E. via yelp.com - Jun 17, 2017
I travel all over the us US and Europe so I have had really good Italian food.. I happened upon this place while on Ride Of The Rockies and I must say this ranks in the top three of the best Italian restaurants I have eaten at in both food quality and service. I can't believe food of this quality is in such a small City. I'll probabl ... read more
Bob Ivy via google.com - Jun 16, 2017
Very good pizza. We were a large group and had several different ones and all excellent! Staff was very friendly with very fast service.
greg born via google.com - Jun 13, 2017
NEVER disappointed when we come here, everything is so delicious, our server was awesome and so pl
NEVER disappointed when we come here, everything is so delicious, our server was awesome and so pleasant! We both had the Antipasto salad, and the Sunshine Peak pizza!
Jan Fenter Allen via facebook.com - Jun 1, 2017
I'm gonna start with the good stuff... Pretty much everything. I had the tastiest salad with mixed
I'm gonna start with the good stuff... Pretty much everything. I had the tastiest salad with mixed greens, dried fruits, and dried corn kernels, and a raspberry vinaigrette dressing (I think) followed by the Pahsagna. Yum. My family enjoyed various pizzas and salads and everything was really tasty and filling as usual. Our server wa ... read more
Sherman Mathieu via facebook.com - May 21, 2017
Highly recommend the cheese steak pizza, so yummy! Deliciousness on every bite.
Highly recommend the cheese steak pizza, so yummy! Deliciousness on every bite.
Lisseth Bergstrom via facebook.com - May 14, 2017
I love this place. Food is great and atmosphere even better. The owner and waitstaff know me by name, remember my order and care about how my day is going.
Jill Burchmore via google.com - May 10, 2017
I am from NYC and here, I had the Best Calzone of my life!!!
Marcialee Brahms via google.com - Apr 17, 2017
Just Good Pizza
Visiting Montrose and stopped by on a whim early Sunday evening. And we are glad we did. Fast and friendly service. Good atmosphere; sitting by the window to enjoy the spring colors outside. We had The Motherlode pizza, thick, buttery crust that melts in your...More ... read more
hausermd via tripadvisor.com - Apr 12, 2017
One word, pizza!
John Shimanovich via google.com - Apr 9, 2017
Food is amazing, high quality local ...
Food is amazing, high quality local ingredients.  Atmosphere not so great - retail space with cold windows.  Alternate design/atmosphere would give 5 stars, LOVE the food!
Debbie M. via yelp.com - Mar 15, 2017
Awsome service, the whole staff was great, awsome atmosphere thank you for all your help!
Awsome service, the whole staff was great, awsome atmosphere thank you for all your help!
Brandy McCullough via facebook.com - Mar 9, 2017
Awesome pizza/food, great, friendly staff. Fantastic.....try it, you won't be sorry!
Awesome pizza/food, great, friendly staff. Fantastic.....try it, you won't be sorry!
Kristine MacKay via facebook.com - Mar 4, 2017
LOVE at first bite!!!
Nice atmosphere, clean, friendly, attentive staff. The prices seem a bit high for pizza at first glance...but the quality and quantity of the ingredients make it well worth it. The philly cheesesteak pizza is AMAZING!! Hubby had the calzone, which was also amazing. It looked...More ... read more
Kristimey2828 via tripadvisor.com - Mar 3, 2017
Sub-stantial !
Delicious meatball sub - freshly prepared, tasty and generous size lots of choice on menu ,friendly staff, good value for money ordered as take-out ,but restaurant itself looked clean and comfortable ... read more
anng99 via tripadvisor.com - Feb 22, 2017
Worth a trip
The pizza and the salads are both worth the trip. This place has the best crust of any pizza I have had in a long time. A bit on the thick side - chewy, crispy and holds up to the toppings. This is the only...More ... read more
Rita B via tripadvisor.com - Feb 13, 2017
Excellent
Take out pizza today for watching the Super Bowl. Its the best. We had a large Pepperoni, tomato and, green pepper. Ummm good.
PhotogChuck via tripadvisor.com - Feb 5, 2017
Nice Ambience
Took a Birthday Girl out for dinner. Pleasantly surprised with the good food and fast service. We all tried something different and hands down the pizza and calzones are the best. Will be back again. A bit pricey for a pizza place, but well worth...More ... read more
CJ D via tripadvisor.com - Feb 3, 2017
I really, really like this place ...
I really, really like this place. The pizza is very tasty. First time we had an "everything on it" sort of pie (I forget the name). The 10" size worked for us but I'm sure many would be able to handle the large. The second time we had the shrimp garlic. It was awesome - sort of to my surprise!Both times we had salads. All of them are ... read more
Rita B. via yelp.com - Jan 24, 2017
Order the small pizza, it cooks up the best ... read more
Joe Davis via google.com - Jan 16, 2017
Really great food. I also appreciate how they source from local farmers. I recommend the build-your-own calzone.
Brett Pfister via google.com - Jan 1, 2017
OK, slow service and the food was a little pricey.
Jess Legere via google.com - Dec 22, 2016
Amazing nature park. The place where a man finds peace.
Łukasz Rozalewicz via google.com - Dec 18, 2016
OK
Not fine dining by any stretch. Glorified fast food, adequately prepared. Slow average service. Nothing to write home about. Seems best for families with kids.
David K via tripadvisor.com - Dec 2, 2016
The food here is so very delicious. Plus, I like that they use local ingredients and veggies when they can.
Donna Replogle via google.com - Nov 11, 2016
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
Google+FoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor